The Lost Toys

The Lost Toys 0
The Lost Toys 1
The Lost Toys 2
The Lost Toys 3
The Lost Toys 4
The Lost Toys 5
The Lost Toys 6

Overview

  • +1 551-389-7744
  • 259 Outwater Ln, Garfield, NJ 07026, USA
  • Hours

    Monday Closed

    Tuesday Closed

    Wednesday 4:00 PM - 7:00 PM

    Thursday 4:00 PM - 7:00 PM

    Friday 4:00 PM - 7:00 PM

    Saturday 1:00 PM - 7:00 PM

    Sunday Closed

The Lost Toys Introduce

Looking for a "Toy Store Near Me" that offers a truly unique and nostalgic experience? Consider The Lost Toys, located at 259 Outwater Ln, Garfield, NJ 07026, USA. You can reach them by phone at (551) 389-7744 or mobile phone at +1 551-389-7744.

Based on glowing customer reviews, The Lost Toys is a "treasure trove" and a "little shop of time jump" for anyone who loves rare and vintage collectibles. The atmosphere is frequently praised, with one visitor describing it as feeling like "catching up with an old friend who happens to have the coolest toy collection." The owner, Joe, is consistently highlighted as an "absolute gem," known for his friendly, humorous, and laid-back approach, making each visit a memorable experience filled with incredible stories.

The store is noted for its "amazing stock" of "well priced childhood memories." Customers have scored impressive finds, including highly sought-after items like the Galactus Hasbro Haslab at an "unbeatable price," Unicron, and Doctor Doom. The shelves are filled with a wide array of collectibles, including popular franchises such as Transformers (including Beast Wars), Star Wars, Power Rangers, Ninja Turtles, G.I. Joes, and more, suggesting a diverse inventory that appeals to various nostalgic interests.

Shopping at The Lost Toys is described as more than just a visit; it's an "experience" that sparks nostalgia and adventure. Joe, the owner, is not only knowledgeable about his stock but also willing to keep an eye out for specific items that customers are interested in. The store is recommended for anyone looking for a one-of-a-kind shopping experience and a chance to discover rare and "lost" collectibles. While the store is described as "little," the enthusiasm of the reviewers suggests it's packed with epic finds. No specific promotional information was mentioned, but the focus on rare items and personalized service indicates that the unique inventory itself is a major draw.

Location

Reviews

  • Feb 25, 2025

    Joe at The Lost Toys is an absolute gem! I picked up the Galactus Hasbro Haslab at an unbeatable price during my first visit, and I was blown away by the atmosphere. Joe’s friendly, humorous, and laid-back approach made the experience feel like catching up with an old friend who happens to have the coolest toy collection. Over my few visits, I’ve also scored a Unicron, Doctor Doom, and heard a whole lot of incredible stories that make each trip memorable. I can’t recommend The Lost Toys enough—it’s a treasure trove for anyone who loves rare, "lost" collectibles. I’m excited to help bring more exposure to Joe’s amazing business because his shop truly deserves a larger space to showcase all these epic finds. If you’re looking for a one-of-a-kind shopping experience that sparks nostalgia and adventure, this is the place to be! V

  • Dec 15, 2024

    Had the pleasure of stumbling upon this little shop of time jump. My boyfriend and I spent our time looking at the amazing stock and having wonderful conversations with Joe the owner. Shopping here was not just a visit but an experience. The shelves are filled with well priced childhood memories and Joe will even keep an eye out for you if you're interested in something specific. As for us, we left with a nice bag of Transformers ( Beast wars too). In sum, we will definitely return for another visit. It's hard to not want to when Star wars, Power Rangers, Ninja Turtles, G.I. Joes and more are looking for new homes. I highly recommend a visit!

  • Oct 17, 2024

    Joe (the owner) is a great guy! The Lost Toys is a great store with great prices and a selection that is unmatched and ever-changing! For classic and vintage toys, there is no place better! We love our trips to this store and you will too!

  • Nov 09, 2024

    The owner is the nicest guy and his selection of vintage toys is as impressive! A must visit for any collector. Hidden gem.

  • Nov 29, 2024

    Stopped by while I was in the area. Very friendly owner and had a pretty wide variety of stuff. Bought some transformers and the prices for them were really fair.

Related Categories

Popular Water Park

game exchange waterbury ct

game exchange waterbury ct

650 Wolcott St, Waterbury, CT 06705, USA

target in orange ct

target in orange ct

25 Boston Post Rd, Orange, CT 06477, USA

game stop middletown ny

game stop middletown ny

400 NY-211 STE 23, Middletown, NY 10940, USA

gamestop in middletown new york

gamestop in middletown new york

400 NY-211 STE 23, Middletown, NY 10940, USA