That's My Collectible

That's My Collectible 0
That's My Collectible 1
That's My Collectible 2
That's My Collectible 3
That's My Collectible 4
That's My Collectible 5
That's My Collectible 6
That's My Collectible 7
That's My Collectible 8
That's My Collectible 9

Overview

  • +1 908-210-1034
  • thatsmycollectible.com
  • 18 Quimby Ln, Bernardsville, NJ 07924, USA
  • Hours

    Monday Closed

    Tuesday Closed

    Wednesday Closed

    Thursday Closed

    Friday 5:00 PM - 8:00 PM

    Saturday 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM

    Sunday 10:00 AM - 2:00 PM

That's My Collectible Introduce

That's My Collectible, located at 18 Quimby Ln, Bernardsville, NJ 07924, is a store specializing in vintage toys and collectibles, particularly those from the 80s and other recent decades. It caters to collectors and those seeking nostalgic items.

Customers consistently praise That's My Collectible for its impressive selection. One customer who visited with their son and friend was "impressed with the selection" and reported that they "all walked out very happy." This indicates a diverse and appealing inventory that caters to various interests.

The store's owners are described as "friendly" and the prices as "great," contributing to a positive shopping experience. Customers appreciate the welcoming atmosphere and the value they receive. The store's recommendation of a nearby Mexican restaurant also highlights the owners' helpfulness and local knowledge.

That's My Collectible is particularly popular among those looking to start or expand their collections of vintage toys. Customers who have sought specific items from their childhood have found success at the store. One customer noted that "when I say they have everything, they have EVERYTHING," emphasizing the store's extensive inventory.

The store's availability in Bernardsville is noted to be until at least April, and they also offer online purchasing and bidding options. This flexibility allows customers to shop in person or remotely, expanding their reach and convenience.

That's My Collectible offers a unique shopping experience for vintage toy and collectible enthusiasts. It is highly recommended for its extensive selection, friendly service, and competitive prices.

For inquiries or purchases, customers can contact the store at (908) 210-1034 or +1 908-210-1034. Visit That's My Collectible for a nostalgic and fulfilling shopping experience, either in-store or online.

Location

Reviews

  • Mar 09, 2025

    Stopped in today with my son and buddy and was impressed with the selection. We all walked out very happy. Great prices and friendly owners. We will definitely come back soon. Also thanks for recommending the Mexican restaurant across the street. Great food to cap off a great day!

  • Jan 16, 2024

    I've always wanted to start collecting 80s toys - you know, the ones I had but foolishly got rid of as I grew up. The good folks at That’s My Collectible have helped me start my collection! You absolutely need to check them out if you're looking for a vintage toy from the last few decades (wow, I sound old when I say that, don't I?) but haven't had any luck. When I say they have everything, they have EVERYTHING. They'll be in Bernardsville until at least April and will have more great stuff to bid on and purchase online. I can't recommend them enough!

  • Jan 16, 2024

    That’s My Collectible was a blast to visit! Brought me back to my childhood! You could spend hours in there getting lost in nostalgia. Fun place, fun vibe, and great customer service! Owners were attentive and knowledgeable. If you are looking for something specific or just a great place to wonder around, get lost for awhile and find that thing you didn’t realize you “needed” stop by for a stroll down memory lane.

  • Jan 21, 2024

    Huge selection and variety of quality products for you choosing at your fingertips! Purchased a couple items will definitely be back for more! Thanks for the help!

  • Jan 21, 2024

    Very friendly , answered all my questions went above and beyond will definitely come back thanks again

Related Categories

Popular Water Park

attic mice 2

attic mice 2

3300 Lehigh St, Allentown, PA 18103, USA

game stop middletown ny

game stop middletown ny

400 NY-211 STE 23, Middletown, NY 10940, USA

gamezone hillsdale nj

gamezone hillsdale nj

106 Broadway, Hillsdale, NJ 07642, USA

target in orange ct

target in orange ct

25 Boston Post Rd, Orange, CT 06477, USA