Lost toys and comics

Lost toys and comics 0
Lost toys and comics 1
Lost toys and comics 2
Lost toys and comics 3
Lost toys and comics 4
Lost toys and comics 5
Lost toys and comics 6
Lost toys and comics 7
Lost toys and comics 8
Lost toys and comics 9

Overview

  • +1 631-743-9443
  • 451 NY-25A Suite 10, Miller Place, NY 11764, USA
  • Hours

    Monday Closed

    Tuesday Closed

    Wednesday Closed

    Thursday Closed

    Friday Closed

    Saturday 12:00 AM - 7:00 PM

    Sunday 12:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Lost toys and comics Introduce

Looking for a unique "Toy Store Near Me" that combines the nostalgia of retro toys with the excitement of comic books and collectibles in Miller Place, New York? Consider Lost Toys and Comics, located at 451 NY-25A Suite 10, Miller Place, NY 11764, USA. You can reach them by phone at (631) 743-9443 or mobile phone at +1 631-743-9443.

Customer reviews describe Lost Toys and Comics as a "very cool store that has a little something for everyone," even appealing to those who don't actively collect toys or comics. The store boasts a diverse inventory, as one visitor who went in looking for Marvel Overpower cards ended up purchasing a whole set of Fright Flicks collectible cards. This suggests a broad appeal beyond just mainstream toys and comics.

A significant highlight is the store's selection of retro toys and comics, offering a "blast from the past" experience. Customers have been surprised to find a substantial number of sealed vintage items, such as Batman toys. The owner, Rob, is consistently praised for being "extremely knowledgeable of all the products he had" and is described as a "personable guy" who is "always in a great mode and loves to talk toys and pop culture." This creates a welcoming and engaging environment for enthusiasts.

The pricing at Lost Toys and Comics is considered "very reasonable" and "pretty fair." Additionally, one reviewer mentioned that "the more you buy the better deal you get," indicating a potential for discounts on multiple purchases. While one customer wished the store carried Pokemon cards, the overall sentiment is that Lost Toys and Comics is a "great toy store" that fills a void in the north shore area.

The environment of Lost Toys and Comics is likely filled with a curated selection of vintage toys, comic books, and various collectibles, creating a nostalgic and exciting space for both serious collectors and casual browsers. The knowledgeable and enthusiastic owner enhances the experience by being readily available to discuss products and pop culture. Key features include a wide range of retro toys (including sealed items), a diverse comic book selection, collectible cards, reasonable pricing with potential multi-buy discounts, and a personable, knowledgeable owner. While no specific ongoing promotions were mentioned, the possibility of better deals for larger purchases is an appealing feature for collectors and gift-givers alike.

Location

Reviews

  • Feb 04, 2025

    Very cool store that has a little something for everyone, even if you don't collect toys or comics (which I don't). I stopped in recently because I saw they had Marvel Overpower cards on their Instagram, and I ended up buying the whole set of Fright Flicks collectible cards while I was there. Prices are very reasonable and the store owner (Rob) is a personable guy. Highly recommended!

  • Sep 28, 2024

    I was absolutely thrilled for this retro toys and comic store to open within walking distance from the house! My wife.. not so thrilled. The store owner rob was extremely knowledgeable of all the products he had. It was a blast from the past to walk in there. I was surprised to see so many sealed Batman toys! There’s something for everyone there. Even my wife found something she had to have there! I’ve been there a few times now and every time rob is in a great mode and loves to talk toys and pop culture! Prices are pretty fair as well and the more you buy the better deal you get! I look forward to returning to complete my Batman animated series collection! If only he had Pokemon cards it would be a one stop shop! Finally the north shore has a great toy store!

  • Feb 03, 2025

    Love this store! The owner, Rob, is a really chill guy and made a store with a very neighborhood feel/atmosphere to it. There's always other collectors popping in and out to "talk shop" with which is easy to do in a smaller shop like this. Selection is great, one wall is all MOC figures from the 80's & 90's, and there's tons of variety to pick from. He also has a decent comic selection, vintage packs of trading cards and lots of loose toys in baggies to buy. GREAT selection of vintage 3.75" G.I. Joe, tons of complete vehicles and loose figures in varying degrees of completion. I try to hit up his store whenever I'm in the area, and it's always a great experience. Can't recommend it enough, go check it out!

  • Feb 03, 2025

    My go to place for anything toys and comics related! Best store around. I was just there yesterday and like always such a great experience and Rob the owner is the best around and he really knows the industry and what he is doing. I was so excited being I picked up some overpower cards which I haven't had since a Kid! Check them out you won't be disappointed!

  • Sep 28, 2024

    Just what the North Shore needed! I stumbled upon this fine establishment during their grand opening. Upon entering I was met with an impressive selection of childhood nostalgia. The gentleman behind the counter Robert was perhaps the most knowledgeable and kindest person I've met in this industry. I even found a comic I was looking for for years. Amazing selection of comics, wrestling figures, and toys from my childhood. Thank you.

Related Categories

Popular Water Park

game exchange waterbury ct

game exchange waterbury ct

650 Wolcott St, Waterbury, CT 06705, USA

kohls newburgh ny

kohls newburgh ny

150 Old Little Britain Rd, Newburgh, NY 12550, USA

gamestop in middletown new york

gamestop in middletown new york

400 NY-211 STE 23, Middletown, NY 10940, USA

attic mice 2

attic mice 2

3300 Lehigh St, Allentown, PA 18103, USA